Contribution of the process of globalization in terms of economic activities has undeniably reflected the international exchange of goods and services, which contributed to new foreign investments, such as capital investments, joint ventures, turnkey projects, technology transfer agreements and others. The fact is that this new trend contributed to economic growth, but at the same time a large number of international trade disputes also appeared. Disputes are always a problem, especially in international transactions, and yet there is no supranational court that would resolve these disputes in accordance with some universal rules, thus we arrive at a situation in which business entities of all kinds can be involved in legal procedures with foreign corporations or governments – in front of foreign courts, faced with a foreign legal culture and foreign law subsumed under a foreign language. Taking into consideration these shortcomings of the national courts, a new alternative mechanism has emerged for the resolution of disputes arising from international trade, that is – settlement of disputes in front of international commercial arbitration.
There are two basic types of agreements for international commercial arbitration, depending on whether it is agreed to settle a dispute that already exists or for disputes that may arise in the future:
1) Submission – this is a special written agreement, the premise of which is the way to resolve an already arising dispute between the parties;
2) Arbitration clause – represents a provision in the commercial agreement, concluded between the parties, which stipulates that all or some disputes that would arise from that agreement in the future will be submitted to arbitration. In practice, most often the arbitration agreement is concluded in this type. The arbitration clause is seen as a routine element of commercial contracts (sales, construction, transportation, insurance, etc.).
The advantage of settling disputes with mechanism of arbitration is the neutrality of arbitration, as an institution that is not part of any national legal system, the greater certainty of obtaining recognition and enforcement of arbitral awards, given the existence of the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of foreign arbitral awards (according to the situation in 2016, it was ratified by 156 countries), the possibility of appointing arbitrators who have professional knowledge and experience in the field that is the subject of the dispute, the confidentiality of the arbitration procedure, which is usually conducted without the presence of the public, and the data are confidential, the one-stage process i.e. the arbitration procedure ends with the adoption of the arbitration decision and no appeal is allowed, which also represents a relative short duration in contrast to court proceedings that last for years and of course the possibility for the parties to determine the place of the arbitration as well as the arbitration composition.
How will the winning party be sure that the arbitration award will be fulfilled by the losing party?
The arbitration decision has the authority of a – res judicata i.e. what is determined or confirmed in the decision should be considered true, and the subject of the decision can no longer be discussed in court or arbitration tribunal, nor submitted appeal – ne bis in idem.
In practice, most of the time, the party that lost the case voluntarily fulfills its obligations, which closes the arbitration process (for example, even 90% of the decisions of the International Court of Arbitration at the International Commercial Arbitration in Paris MTK – ICC – are fulfilled voluntarily). But there is always a second option, the party that lost the dispute, dissatisfied with the outcome, refuses to fulfill its obligations. In this case, the party who won the case has two solutions available:
1) Use of a form of pressure, which may be of a financial nature, negative publicity to which the losing party is exposed i.e. posting on a notice board at the headquarters of the Chamber of Commerce, prohibition to present its disputes before institutional arbitration in the future i.e. the name of the party is put on a black list and finally, the most severe sanction is the exclusion of the losing party from the trade association within which the institutional arbitration operates and;
2) Enforcement by state courts. Since the subject of execution is the property of the debtor, two situations are possible. In the first one, it would approach forced execution in the country in which the arbitration decision is considered domestic and in the second situation, when it is necessary for the arbitration decision to be forcibly executed in a country in which it is not considered domestic i.e. where it is treated as foreign decision.
At the world level, the number of successfully concluded disputes in front of arbitration as well as the number of arbitration processes that are in progress is continuously increasing. According to certain estimates presented in legal theory, about 90% of international trade agreements contain an arbitration clause.
Bearing this fact in mind, the question arises – are business entities from the Republic of Macedonia sufficiently familiar with the arbitration mechanism and how it works, or would they rather agree that disputes containing an international element should be resolved exclusively in front of court?
Does the Republic of N. Macedonia is ready for the challenges that globalization brings and will it succeed in developing the necessary flexibility in resolving disputes by developing trust among business entities in relation to arbitration?